SWAMY SHARDANAND JI WAS IN FACT NETA JI SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE, PLEASE READ THIS BLOG:
I am compelled to write this blog to expose mission Neta ji
and its organizers Sayantan Das Gupta and Anuj Dhar. Though I am fully aware of
their dedication to prove that Neta ji was alive after 1945 and he didn’t die
in air crash on said date 18th August 1945.
The Mukarji commission was set to find out the following facts as;
1- Whether Neta Subhash Chandra bose is dead or alive;
2- If he is dead, whether he dies in the plane crash, as
alleged;
3- Whether the ashes in the Japanese temple are ashes of
Neta ji;
4- Whether he has dies in any other manner at any other
place and, if so, when and how;
5- If he is alive, in respect of his whereabouts.
Mr. Mukarji did an appreciable job in finding some of the facts like he established that Neta ji didn’t die in air crash in
Now let us try to find the answers of remaining last two
questions.
Mukarji had to answer of this question….4- Whether he has
dies in any other manner at any other place and, if so, when and how;
To answer this question Mukarji had to see three persons on
his list if out of these three who could be Neta ji or not. These persons were
:
1-Swami Shardanand of Shoulmari ashram died at Dehra Dun ,
2- Bhagwan ji from Faizabadand and,
3- Sadhu Jyotirdev from Sheopurkalan(MP)
Here Justice Mukarji tried to hush up the mystery on death
of Subhash bose. He went Dehra Dun
to collect evidence but unfortunately or deliberately he didn’t visit his
ashram at 194, Rajpur Road .
No inquiry was made at that ashram, from nearby residents or any eminent
persons in Dehra dun
who witnessed the cremation of Neta ji. He didn’t ask the administration to
verify reports of draping the deadbody of said swami ji alias Neta ji in
National Tri-color and give a 21 gun salute to the deceased before cremation to
give FULL STATE AND MILITARY HONOR. No inquiry was made from the truck owner
whose truck was hired to carry the body of neta ji. Why the deadbody of Neta ji
was kept for 10 days before cremation by administration? Why a wireless message
was sent by governor of UP to local police to escort the VIP? Why the
identification and status of that VIP is never disclosed? Who were the eminent
personalities visited there from India and abroad? Whether any
family member was also present in funeral of Netaji? By whose orders the
decision to drape the dead body in national Tri color was taken and who passed
the order for a full state military honor to the former head of nation (nine
axis countries had recognized) and to a former Commander of organized army? All
these questions remained unanswered.
Mr. Mukarji just visited Dehra Dun . His visit was earlier informed to
col. Pritam singh who was the president/ controller of ashram who was at his
home at village Khairi, Doiwala about 30 kms from main city of dehra Dun . Mr. Mukarji
went to his home and stayed overnight there, enjoyed his hospitality and came
back, and closed his search at Dehra
Dun .
Col. Pritam Singh was also abided by an oath to Neta ji to hide his identity and never to reveal it. He was a committed soldier and loyal to Neta ji. He denied Swami Shardanand as Neta ji.
Justice Mukarji was an experienced judge and retired from prestigious service. How could he blindly trusted Col. Pritam Singh without keeping him in question box? I am just a follower of Neta ji and revealed many things. When I reached to meet col. Pritam Singh, he was not feeling well. He was 92 at that time and I was not in a position to insist him on to answer my questions so I was refraining myself to ask only important questions.
So I had decided to show him the said picture taken beside dead body of Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru at Teen Murti Bhawan,
Col. Pritam Singh being
examined by Sh. RN Sharma
We reached village Khairi where Col. Pritam singh was
running a school in the name of subhash as Subhash academy. His son was also
present there. He welcomed us and introduced to his father. After introduction,
I took out the picture and asked Col. Pritam singh to recognize the person in
picture. Though being an old person, he recognized immediately in first glance
and replied promptly…NETA JI AUR KAUN? (Neta ji who else)?
PAHCHANIYE KAUN….?
“MEN MAY LIE BUT
CIRCUMSTANCES DO NOT” Viewers please compare both the pictures of Subhash for the evidence of
identification.
My task was almost complete by this answer. I uncovered the
picture and asked again if Neta ji died in 1945 then how was he seen in this
picture which was taken after the death of Nehru in 1964? He was just stunned,
speechless and could not believe. He was smart enough to escape from my
questions but now he was caught. So he looked for a few seconds in my eyes and
replied a bit rudely…immediately
he turned from the track and said, ”Photo to koi bhi
banaa saktaa hai.” I replied this is a real photo taken beside the
dead body of the late Prime Minister Sh. J. N. Nehru in 1964. He further said… Go and ask
Nehru or Edwina or go to Yarktusk Jail, Syberia where he was lodged in cell no
465.
Here he again approved me another fact that Neta ji was in Yarktusk Jail which was revealed earlier by …..who was also lodged in an adjoining cell in same jail. So he approved that Neta ji didn’t die in air crash. And he was alive. Neta ji was known in this jail as a monk KHILSAI MALANG. But before that we proceed ahead, let us whether this picture is really of Neta ji or the monk which was informed to khosla commission after 10 years. It’s to be noted that after giving independence to India the British government published top-secret document about India in a book ‘Transfer of power 1943-47’ The British government was in possession of information that Subhash Chandra Bose didn’t die in air crash on 18th August 1945. This report would be made available in AD 2021.
In
1946, the central intelligence deptt. submitted a confidential report to
viceroy Wavell that Subhash Chandra bose communicated wit Nehruand that he was
living in Moscow
under assumed name of “Gizai Malan”. The report claimed that this information
was disclosed by the Russian ambassador in Kabul
and the Russian vice-Counsel at Tehran .
Indian ambassador in Russia, Satyanarain Sinha met Abani Mukarji’s son Goga who
told him thatNeta ji was locked in the adjoining cell of his father under the
name” Khisai Malang” in Gulag, Siberia.
The
names GIZAI MALAN and Khisai Malanag are very similar while pronounced by a
European.
I further asked him about his telegram sent to the President of India and copied to PM & home minister of India in which he alleged one Inder singh to grab the land of Shaulmari ashram at 194 rajpur road, dehra dun in which he mentioned that…”is ashram se bharat ke gaurav ke prashth jude hain…..’ means that the golden pages of India are connected with this ashram.
I asked to define this line but he didn’t answer. There is a coded message hidden in this line that the ashram has its linage with Neta ji and he reminded the high ups through this telegram and requested to be helped.
Please see the
copy of telegram;
I insisted many times to
disclose this, the meanings of this line. What was that pride (the secret
pride) he mentioned but every time his reply was that Swamiji was a man of high
spirituality though he did not disclose the real identity.
He might
not disclosed but it was already made to public by Sh.
Uttam Chand Malhotra in July 1962, and earlier by Maj. Satya Gupta in a press
conference at Calcutta in Feb.1962 after he met Swamiji alias Netaji and
disclosed that Swami Shardanandji of Shaulmari Ashram was in fact Netaji
Subhash Chandra Bose. It was only indicated in telegram. (See picture above).
On the basis of the
complaint to hon’le president and Prime Minister of India by Col. Pritam Singh, Mr. O. P. Sharma also lodged a complaint on land
grabbing. The District Magistrate/collector initiated the
inquiry. The inquiry officer sent back the report without recording any
statement of the complainant Sh. O. P. Sharma, and filed the remark that with his inquiry it does not prove and no proof of Swamiji’s being
as Netaji could be found and land grabbing by one Inder Singh Khatri was
found baseless. It was purchased by him from the real owners in
2001. Col. Pritam Singh denied the charges made by him and also did not commit
that Swamiji /Netaji was one person. So the charges made in complaint were
found baseless. No action was taken against the land grabber Inder Singh.
This officer was not
appointed to find the facts if Swamiji/ Netaji was one person. In his opinion
there was no need of any commission to probe as he himself had given the
verdict. He was deployed to inquire the charges of land grabbing. Nothing else.
he was not concerned if Late Swamiji was Netaji or not but he should have gone
on the contents of the complaint and of allegations made within.
The three commission whatsoever
declared after a long probe in diffrent countries, a police inspector did the
same work in just one inquiry. The matter was closed after this and final
report was submitted. What a great idea?
The meeting ended after about 2 hrs. My
conclusion of this interview is that, not only Netaji made any commitment to
the Govt. of India and Russia
before his release and his re-entry to India , his motherland, but he also
did commit on behalf of all his men from INA that no one will ever disclose his
identity. They (INA men) have taken an OATH OF SECRECY before
him to not to disclose that Swami Shardanand is none other than Netaji Subhash
Bose. These Men from INA, are true soldiers who being abided by their oath,
shall never disclose the evidence of identity of there Supreme Commander.
Result whatsoever may be.
No doubt they are loyal, dedicated and true
soldiers. Any nation of having such dedicated soldiers, having spirit like
them, the saviors of nation, would feel proud upon them and his strength of
dedicated army but I am sorry to say they are loyal to Subhash only. This was
also a reason they were not adjusted in Indian army after independence. The
Govt. was feared, that in future they could be provoked and revolt in favor of
Subhash. On the recommendation of Lord Mountbatten,and agreed by Nehru, a
precondition for independence the INA soldiers were not re-inducted into the
Indian Army.
The
same question was asked from Anuj Dhar but he had no answer.
In
this picture I asked Anuj dhar to decode the hidden message in the telegram
sent to the President of India, the copies were also sent to Home Minister and
the Prime minister of India
by Col. Pritam singh. He could not answer.
In
this comment Anuj Dhar responded me and tried to win my trust.
In
this comment I criticized Anuj Dhar that he had written two books, among them
the previous one was ‘back from dead’. In this book he asked few questions, I
wrote that I am ready to answer those questions but would he dare to answer my
questions? It was not a personal attack but as a critic of what he has written,
I offered him to answer his questions. Then I informed him that I am aware that
he lost his job from Hindustan times as he
jeopardized with them. It was his duty to give all collected information to his
employer but he used for his own use only. He opened a website and collected
funds. Could he give any detail of collected funds and their expenditures?
Now
after this debate got sore. The person Abhishek singh, on whose wall on
facebook this debate was going on suddenly started getting rude and tried to
twist the topic. But I just tried to bring him back on right track but failed.
Here
Anuj Dhar just tried to divert my attention, but he didn’t reply the asked
question to decode the message.
My
words alleging Anuj Dhar on treason with Hindustan
times ignited him so Abhishek Singh abused me filthy language and I blocked
him. Thus the debate ended. I am sure that Anuj dhar and his party who are
running a website as Mission Neta ji are totally fake. It seems as they are
being paid by govt. of India
to divert the Indian public from true revelations made by myself Ajmer Singh Randhawa
and Shri Suresh Padhye from Amravati .
Just look ahead how I reveal more truths in support my assertions.
This is the picture of
Swami Shardanand of Shaulmari Ashram,(Subhash Chandra Bose) beside the dead body
of Late Prime Minister, Sh. JN Nehru in 1964.
Anujdhar
& Co have been propagating false things like Veera Dhammvara story......So
sharing these crucial pieces of info here...To be Thrown on their face :
(B) This monk is Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, without any shadow of
doubt...Why are we so convinced?
ANSWER
: In the month of
May,1964,when the entire Nation was harping the same note,when the the issue
raised to an international height, when the Govt of India was at a total
loss,what could have been done to settle everything very easily?...the answer
is very simple!...that so called 'Cambodian Monk' could have been brought in
public immediately...as this so called 'Cambodian Monk' was a V.I.P,the Govt
had full knowledge about his identity,whereabouts...had that so called
'Cambodian Monk' been summoned by Govt and had this photograph been showed
alongside the monk,then everybody would surely have accepted that the Monk
beside Nehru was not Netaji at all but this so called 'Cambodian
Monk'...now,how long does it take to fly in that monk from any corner of the
World?...24 hours, 48 hours, 1 week, 2 weeks, maximum 1 month...he arrived
after 10 long years...a decade!!...during the final sessions of Khosla
commission in 1974...there he made some funny comments: I was amused blah blah
blah...our question is my dear Cambodian Monk, where had you been all these
years?...An Entire Decade!!!
The Governments of India
have been playing and will surely play a little longer...After that?
The
Incident In Detail - On 28/05/1964,Netaji, along with some Buddhist Monks
arrived at the Teen murthy Bhawan(the mortal body of Nehru was kept there) on
three taxis...time was approx 11am...Shri Gulzarilal Nanda was then
the interim Prime Minister of India...Shri Lal Bahadur Shastri was
given the responsibility to welcome/handle V.I.P Guests...From the taxi,
Netaji sent an envelope to Shri Shastri and Shri Shastri came running
to welcome him...Then Lal Bahadur ji and Netaji went inside the Teen
Murthy Bhawan.....After that Netaji arrived beside Nehru's body and offered
a giant garland of roses as homage...Netaji also added a note to
the garland in English...The note said,"Another name of Jawaharlal
Nehru is courage.Let us confront the crisis of our nation for the future
of India"...The note was undersigned as 'Subhas Chandra Bose'.
Now, let
us discuss about the consequences of that documentary film...It gave rise to a
huge uproar across the country...Not only did it shook India,waves hit beyond
Indian boundary...80 Members of Parliament visited PM Shri Lalabahadur Shastri
and proclaimed that the Monk was Netaji SubhasChandra Bose,without any shadow
of doubt...Shastriji could not reply anything ever!...This photograph also sent
a ripple in England...It was published in very important newspapers like Daily
Mail,London Times etc,with a caption - 'Tell India! Who is this Swamiji!'.
Now,what
did the Govt of India do?...They had been shaken to such an extent that the
part of that film was totally censored...As I have earlier mentioned that
the documentary film(film number-816B) has been a big headache for the Govt of
India,they wanted to bury it once and for all...In that effort,a so called
'Cambodian Monk' called Veera Dhammavara (Deponent number 224)was sent to
the Khosla commission in 1974 during the final session,to misguide/bluff the
commission...Veera Dhammavara story turned out to be a superflop,as it should!
So its clear that
the monk was none other then Neta ji only. His picture was recognized by Col.
Pritam singh and almost every Indian in first glance approves it.
Now the question
arises if he was Neta ji, why did he go in hide? To get the answer kindly see
this revelation;
Surendra Mohan Ghosh was inmate of Neta ji in
Mandlalay jail in Burma .
He became Deputy speaker of the Parliament. Jawaharlal Nehru deputed him to
confirm whether the person concerned in Shaulmari Ashram was Subhash Bose or
not who was publicized by Major Satya Gupta former officer of INA, who revealed
in a press conference in Calcutta that ‘DOG CAN NOT FORGET HIS MASTER’, Dr.
gope Gurbax and Haripad Bose of Shaulmari Ashram, Uttamchand Malhotra, Hira lal
dixit and Subhashwadi Janata proclaimed that his holiness Sahrdanand ji was
Subhash Bose.
Surendra Mohan Ghosh didn’t give a positive report
to Nehru but he (Nehru) never disclosed it. However Nehru got the shock of his
life and ordered department of intelligence to keep round the clock
surveillance. Mr. Dixit of the Central Intelligence tried to murder Shardanand
ji but the vigilant bodyguards caught him red handed. The govt. set Mr. Dixit
scot-free on the ground of lunacy. Hereafter Dr. BC Roy
CM of Bengal, deputed state police to safeguard Shardanand ji. On this issue Dr. BC Roy
had differences with Nehru and Nehru wanted BC roy
to resign, as Chief minister of Bengal .
To-day on
26-02-2009, I have got the copy of a news report published in Indian express on
July 01-2003, in which an ex-principal claimed that Swami Shardanand ji was
Neta ji . He was openly admitted by Swamiji himself in 1976 at Dehra Dun that he was Subhash Chandra Bose.
See the report; Ex-principal claims Netaji was alive till 1977
VIVEK DESHPANDE Posted: Jul 01, 2003 at 0000 hrs IST AMRAVATI, JUNE 30: Shall we ever know for sure if Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose really died in a plane crash in 1945, or if he went on to survive till 1977 in the disguise of a spiritual guru? Well, the Mukherjee Commission, the third one to probe the mysterious death, is well on course. But for retired principal S.S. Padhye, there’s not an iota of doubt that Netaji lived till 1977.
Padhye, in his seventies, claims he was in close touch with Netaji between 1964 and 1971 and even hid him for four months in the Melghat forest when Intelligence personnel were on his trail. The innumerable papers and pictures he has clearly rubbish the crash death theory, he claims.
WHY
NETA JI WENT INTO HIDE, THE REASON IS ALREADY ANSWERED ABOVE.
9.
I have already given address of Spanish tourist who took many photographs of
Netaji on pyre with his colored Polaroid Camera. Either directly or from the
Embassy of Spain they may be acquired. http://netajibosemysteryrevealed.org/dissection-of-justice-mukherjee-commission-of-inquiry-jmci/
Shri Suresh Padhye sent some
questions and requests to Mukarji commission. At no 9 in his list he requests
to call the Spanish tourists who visited Rishikesh, Dehra Dun on funeral of Neta ji and captured
the last moments in their camera.Justice Mukarji never tried to contact of find
those Spanish tourists.
Fortunately those Spanish tourists themselves contacted me through internet and sent me 13 pictures. I am pasting few important pictures here also to share with you.
The
picture of both the Spanish tourists who took pictures at funeral.
Last glimpse of Neta ji
The pyre of Neta
ji at Triveni Ghat, Rishikesh, Dehra Dun
Dr. Ramni Ranjan Das ,while merging the ashes of
Swamiji in river Ganga, at Rishikesh said, "Netaji, He has finished the
task with complete devotion, assigned to him, now by merging the ashes (Of
Netaji) in holy Ganga." Mr.Inderpal Singh S.H.O. Rajpur, Dehra Dun , was present beside him. He heard him saying so and
asked him that until than he was misguiding police that the deceased was not
Subhash but by listening his words carefully, now he too believes that the
deceased was certainly the great leader and freedom fighter Subhash Chandra
Bose. This is certified by Sh. Inderpal Singh ji.
Those who witnessed the last procession of Netaji and had paid
their homage to departed soul, have seen the body was draped in national
Tri-color and he was given a FULL STATE MILITARY HONOR by 21 gund salutes and
turning the rifles upside down to mark their respect to former state of head
and an ex-commander of legalized army called INA.
When I asked this question to Anuj Dhar, he starts to twist the
topic as this honor was not given to Gumnami baba at Faizabad where he died in
1985. Why?
I ask all readers also, if they could ask the govt. of
Swami Shardanand ji had expired on 9th April but by order of
Now let us see the other point of Mukarji commission’s report
about Gumnami Baba at Faizabad.
I saw a comment on website of Sh. Suresh Padhye written by
Sayantan Das Gupta of Mission Neta ji, just view it below. I too wrote another
comment just next to it. Since then I was waiting for the opportunity to have
arguments with either Sayantan Das or his associate Anuj Dhar.
But Sayantan das Gupta left the
debate very soon and it could not be found fruitful. He also threatened to sue me in
court as this team always threat.
Justice Mukarji in his report on page no 121, vol-1, writes
that….4.15.9…The reports of the experts to whom the hand writings appearing in
some books and journals found in the Rambhawan were sent for comparison with
the admitted handwritings of Netaji materially differ. While one of them viz. Shri B. Lal, ex-govt.
Examiner of Questioned Documents, New Delhi(CW 119) has given a firm opinion
that those (both Bengali and Engish) were of Netaji, Shri Amar singh and Shri M
L Sharma (CW 121) of the office of the Govt, Examiner of Questioned documents,
GOI, Simla. Who have filed a joint report, and Dr. SK Mondal of Forensic
Science Laboratory, Govt. of West Bengal, kolkata (CW 120) have given a
contrary opinion. Such divergent opinion and absence of any evidence from any
person conversant with the handwriting of Neta ji that the questioned writings
were of Netaji is another impediment to the safe acceptance of the oral version
given in this regard.
Justice
Mukarji sent (4.15.10) five teeth out of nine, found in Ram Bhavan along with
samples of blood collected from two descendants on the father’s side and three
descendants on the mother’s side of Neta ji were sent to the Central Forensic
Laboratory, Kolkata for DNA profiling test to fix the identity of person to
whom the teeth belonged. After subjecting three out of five teeth to the above
test Dr. VK Kashyap, DNA Expert and Director of the Laboratory submitted a
detailed report with the following opinion:” From the microphological
examination and analysis of SRY gene, mt DNA (HVS I& HVS II) and Y_STR loci
in the forwarded exhibits 1- 10, it can be concluded that forwarded teeth –
(Exhibits 2 to 4) belong to a single human aged male individual – source of the
teeth does not belong to either maternal or paternal DNA lineage of Netaji
Subhash Chandra Bose, therefore, can not be of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.”
Then
justice Mukarji closes his report on the same page as….
4.15.12… In fine, in absence of any clinching evidence to prove that Bhagwanji/ Gumnami baba was Netaji nd the question whether he (Netaji) dies in Faizabad on September 16, 1985 as testified by some of the witnesses, need not be answered.
I
also said in my blogs before I read this report that just by recovery of some
belongings from the possession of a dead person, the deceased can not be
identified as the master of those belongings. Like if my some wallet, identity
cards etc are stolen the thief gets die somehow with his face disembarked, he
can not be proved I am dead. DNA of deceased bhagwan ji proved it that he was
not Netaji.
Now
let us see about Shopurkalan: (page 1120)
4.14…
There was a sadhu named Jyotirdev, used to correspond regularly with senior
officers and used to go out of the village frequently, according to shri
Jagnanath Prasad gupta the sadhu was none other then Netaji. And he died on May
21, 1977 in Sheopurkalan. He lastly stated that after his death the govt. of
Madhya Pradesh seized all records pertaining to be the ‘Sadhu’ and, according
to him, those documents contained proof of his identity as Netaji.
4.14.1…
in course of inquiry the commission examined all the above persons at Sheopurkalan.
None of them had seen Netaji earlier.(4.14.2) nor are the documents filed by
them have any relevance to the issue. Besides the documents seized by police
from the residence of the sadhu after his death at the instance of sh. Gupta
didn’t at all support his contention that those documents would unmistakably
prove that the ‘sadhu’ was Netaji.
Conclusion:
Now after we analysed the report of Justice Mukarji, we found he rejected all the three personalities and couold not establish anybody among them as Netaji, But in case of Shardanand ji, he deliberately tried to cover up the facts. Neither he visited the ashrm, nor inquired from any person in Dehra dun , ignored this telegram and never
asked hidden message from Col. Pritam Singh. He didn't make any effort to contact
the Spanish tourists who all of sudden arrived Rishikesh and witnessed the high
profile funeral and took some pictures. The same pictures were also taken by police
photographer Sardar Jogi ji which are never disclosed why? He also ignored the
police officers on duty who saw every visitor and recorded their visit in
diary. Who were those visitors and where did they come from, NO INFORMATION.
Now after we analysed the report of Justice Mukarji, we found he rejected all the three personalities and couold not establish anybody among them as Netaji, But in case of Shardanand ji, he deliberately tried to cover up the facts. Neither he visited the ashrm, nor inquired from any person in D
So I have concluded by searching all facts and by seeing myself that the Swami Shardanand ji was in fact Neta ji. I have written in detail on my website www.deathofsubhashbose.com/ and in my many blogs (links given below) and in my book written in hindi language so that every Indian may read it and come to know the truth. This book can also be read online in blog (written in two parts and linked online).:
http://antimsatyasubhashbose.blogspot.com/ (Part one)
http://antimsatyaasubhashbose.blogspot.com/
(Part two)
The
curious followers of Neta ji are adviced to visit this website as the owner of
this website shri suresh Padhye spent many years of his life with Neta ji in
free India .
He has many evidences to prove but as the govt has no intention to show the
world that Neta ji was alive and spent his last days in India , we find it difficult to whom
we should show the evidences.
http://subhashji.blogspot.com (To view in Hindi)
http://subhash-jaihind.blogspot.com (To view in Bengali)
http://legendsubhash.blogspot.com (for my witness only)
Ajmer Singh Randhawa
0091- 9818610698
E-mail doonsikh13@gmail.com